PumpkinVine prop firm challenge: why monthly return claims should not drive your decision

5 min readBy PumpkinVine

Key takeaways

In a PumpkinVine prop firm challenge, the official rules set no monthly unit. Apart from the minimum trading days there is no hard time limit, and the evaluation is measured by profit target, drawdown cap and qualifying days.

Deep navy abstract illustration with a thin white line carrying small hollow squares near the upper left and one long diagonal line across the right side

In a PumpkinVine prop firm challenge, the official rules set no monthly unit. Apart from the minimum trading days there is no hard time limit, and the evaluation is measured by profit target, drawdown cap and qualifying days.

Does the official rule set a fixed length for the evaluation period

No. The official Guide states that there is no hard time limit apart from the minimum trading days, and separately that an account may be closed after 30 days of inactivity. Time is not counted in months.

What the evaluation period is actually measured against

Three sets of numbers. The profit target is 8% then 5% on the two-step path and 10% on the one-step path. The drawdown cap is 10% static in the two-step evaluation phase and 8% in the funded phase, and 6% static end to end on the one-step path, with daily loss caps of 5% and 4%. Each evaluation phase also requires at least 3 qualifying days. None of these is expressed per month.

Are qualifying days and valid trades a form of time measure

They are, but they measure trading behaviour rather than the calendar. A qualifying day requires one complete open and close on that day, that position held for more than 60 seconds, and a margin peak of at least 1% of the initial account size. Ten scalping trades in one day do not necessarily produce a qualifying day.

Is there a monthly payout cycle in the payout stage

There is not. The official rules state that a request can be submitted once the current cycle has 5 qualifying trading days, with no Sunday batching and no fixed batch schedule. The Best Day 50% rule and a minimum of 100 USDT in eligible profit apply at the same time, with a default split of 80% and up to 90% in designated promotions.

Can the platform's own scale figures support a monthly return claim

No. The 300,000 traders, 50-plus countries, 13 regional operating centres including Singapore and Hong Kong, China, and the guarantee fund of over USD 30 million are platform disclosures that cannot be verified externally.

What can be checked is the operating entity and licence: Killara Securities PTY LTD of Sydney, Australia, holds Australian ASIC licence number 001322159, and both are searchable in the public register.

Does the funded account earn money from the real market

No. The official text states that both the evaluation account and the funded account are simulated, and that profit paid to those who pass comes from fees paid by those who do not, plus partner-sponsored selection funds. A monthly return figure circulated elsewhere cannot be mapped onto any product the platform discloses.

Rule item Value Common misreading (not true)
Evaluation time limit No hard limit apart from the minimum trading days "The evaluation has to finish inside one month" is not true
Minimum trading days At least 3 qualifying days per evaluation phase "Hitting the target in one day is enough" is not true
Profit target 8% then 5% on the two-step path, 10% on the one-step path "The target is settled monthly" is not true
Total drawdown 10% static in the two-step evaluation phase, 8% in the funded phase, 6% static on the one-step path "The drawdown cap resets every month" is not true
Daily drawdown 5% on the two-step path, 4% on the one-step path "Daily loss is converted into a monthly figure" is not true
Account activity An account may be closed after 30 days of inactivity "An idle account stays valid indefinitely" is not true
Payout timing Submit once the current cycle has 5 qualifying trading days, no Sunday batching "There is one fixed payout window per month" is not true
Account nature Both the evaluation account and the funded account are simulated "Funded account profit comes from the real market" is not true
Common claim Official position Common misreading (not true)
"A steady monthly percentage is achievable" The rules contain no monthly metric; the evaluation is measured by target and qualifying days "The platform assesses and pays out monthly" is not true
"A larger guarantee fund means more safety" The fund of over USD 30 million is a platform disclosure that cannot be verified externally "The fund size can be checked publicly" is not true
"The trader count proves the model is proven" The 300,000 traders and 13 regional operating centres are also platform disclosures "Scale figures can be independently verified" is not true
"An account can sit idle indefinitely" An account may be closed after 30 days of inactivity "An evaluation account never expires" is not true

The positions above come from the official published rule text and the official Guide, and each can be checked against the source. Where rules are updated, the official text prevails.

The operating entity is Killara Securities PTY LTD of Sydney, Australia, holding Australian ASIC licence number 001322159; the entity and the licence number can be looked up in the Australian public register.

This content is for reference only and does not constitute investment advice. All figures quoted here come from the official published rule text and the official Guide.

Author: PumpkinVine Content Team|Updated: 2026-11-18


Risk notice: This content is for reference only and does not constitute investment advice. Trading derivatives and contracts for difference involves high risk and may result in the loss of all or part of your capital. Read the rules and consider your own risk tolerance before deciding whether to take part. PumpkinVine does not solicit participation from residents of mainland China.

FAQ

Is there a monthly fee on a PumpkinVine prop firm challenge?

There is no monthly fee in the proprietary model. A challenge account is a one-off payment, and advanced AI features are charged as a subscription.

How long can the evaluation period run?

There is no hard time limit apart from the minimum trading days, but an account may be closed after 30 days of inactivity.

Is the profit target settled monthly?

No. The target is a percentage, 8% then 5% on the two-step path and 10% on the one-step path, and each evaluation phase also requires at least 3 qualifying days.

Can extra trades in one day manufacture a qualifying day?

Not by trade count alone. A qualifying day requires one complete open and close, that position held for more than 60 seconds, and a margin peak of at least 1% of the initial account size. A valid trade also requires a holding period of more than 60 seconds, and adding or reducing positions does not create a new trade.

Is the payout made once a month?

No. The rules state that a request can be submitted once the current cycle has 5 qualifying trading days, with no Sunday batching and no fixed batch schedule, and that the Best Day 50% rule and the 100 USDT minimum eligible profit must both be met.

Tagsprop firm challengeevaluation rulesdrawdown limitssimulated environment