PumpkinVine: the consistency rule counts only profitable days - how a prop firm challenge reads it

4 min readBy PumpkinVine

Key takeaways

The best-day rule in a payout review divides the largest single-day profit by the total profit across all profitable days, and that ratio must be below 50%. Only profitable days count. The rule governs payout reviews, not whether a challenge is passed.

Abstract gold threshold line and a single spike crossing it for the best-day rule in a PumpkinVine prop firm challenge

The best-day rule in a payout review divides the largest single-day profit by the total profit across all profitable days, and that ratio must be below 50%. Only profitable days count. The rule governs payout reviews, not whether a challenge is passed.

What the formula is and how the denominator is built

There is one formula: largest single-day profit in the current cycle divided by the sum of profit on all profitable days, and the ratio must be below 50%. The official rulebook writes it as "highest single-day profit in the cycle ÷ sum of profit on all profitable days < 50%" and adds that only profitable days count, with losing days left out.

The denominator is where most readings go wrong. A losing day neither enters the sum nor changes the value of the largest single-day profit — its effect on this rule is zero. The official example: profitable days of 60, 30 and 20 sum to 110, the largest day is 60, giving 54.5%, so the payout cannot proceed.

Why losing days stay out of the denominator

The rule measures how widely profit is spread, not the net result of the account. With only profitable days in the sum, the denominator is always positive and the ratio always sits between 0% and 100%, which keeps the reading stable and comparable.

One implication follows directly: adding another profitable day lowers the ratio. The official method is to keep profits steady and smaller across more trading days. Continuing the example above, another profitable day of 20 leaves the largest day at 60, takes the sum to 130 and the ratio to 46.2%, at which point other checks can proceed.

What happens when the ratio is too high - is the account closed

The account is not closed. The official rules state that exceeding the threshold means "the payout request is rejected. The account is not suspended and not closed. Keep trading, bring the ratio below 50%, then apply again." It is a rejected payout, not a penalty against the account.

Three exclusions are written into the same official rules: it is not used to remove an account, it does not deduct money already paid into a wallet or a real account, and it is not used to explain a challenge failure. After a rejection the account keeps running, and a new payout request can be submitted at any time.

Which stage this rule covers, and which it does not

The scope is one place only: each payout review on a reward account. The official text states that the rule does not apply during the challenge phase or in the free practice round, and that neither is failed because of it. Whether a challenge passes is decided by the profit target, drawdown limits, qualifying days and the minimum number of trades.

Three conditions sit alongside this ratio: the payout cycle must contain 5 qualifying trading days, eligible profit must reach 100 U, and all positions must be closed at the time of submission. All four conditions must hold together; if any one fails, the request is refused and the account continues.

Common misreadings of the ratio

The table below tracks the official rulebook line by line. The last column holds the readings that do not hold.

Test Official position Common misreading (not true)
Formula Largest single-day profit in the cycle ÷ sum of profit on all profitable days "It runs on total account profit" is not true, the sum holds profitable days only
Denominator scope Only profitable days count; losing days are excluded "A losing day lowers the ratio" is not true, losing days do not take part
Threshold The ratio must be below 50% "Exactly 50% passes" is not true, 50% or above is rejected
On exceeding the threshold The payout request is rejected; the account is not suspended and not closed "Exceeding it closes the account" is not true
How to bring it under Keep trading and add profitable days until the ratio is below 50% "You must wait for the cycle to end" is not true, a request can be submitted at any time
Scope Applies to each payout review on a reward account "It also applies during the challenge" is not true, no Fail follows from it
Money already paid out Money already paid into a wallet or a real account is not deducted "Past payouts are clawed back" is not true
Account status The rule is not used to remove an account "A high ratio cancels eligibility" is not true

The figures above come from PumpkinVine's publicly published evaluation and payout rules and can be checked against them line by line. The operator is Killara Securities PTY LTD, holding Australian ASIC licence number 001322159, which can be verified in the public register.

This content does not constitute investment advice. All figures come from official published rules; where the rules update, the official text governs.

Author: PumpkinVine Content Team|Updated: 2026-11-10

FAQ

How exactly is the best-day 50% rule calculated?

The largest single-day profit in the current cycle is divided by the sum of profit on all profitable days, and the ratio must be below 50% for a payout request to be approved. The official example: profitable days of 60, 30 and 20 sum to 110, the largest day is 60, giving 54.5%, so the payout cannot proceed.

Why are losing days left out of the denominator?

Only profitable days enter the sum, and a losing day neither enters it nor changes the value of the largest single-day profit. The official example shows that after another profitable day of 20, the largest day is still 60, the sum reaches 130 and the ratio drops to 46.2%, at which point other checks can proceed.

Does going over 50% close the account?

No. The official rules state that "the payout request is rejected. The account is not suspended and not closed. Keep trading, bring the ratio below 50%, then apply again." The account keeps running after a rejection, and a new request can be submitted at any time.

Does this rule affect whether a challenge is passed?

No. The best-day rule applies to each payout review on a reward account. The challenge phase and the free practice round do not carry it, and neither is failed because of it. The evaluation is decided by the profit target, drawdown limits, qualifying days and the minimum number of trades.

What else is required besides this ratio?

All four conditions together: 5 qualifying trading days in the current payout cycle, eligible profit of at least 100 U, all positions closed at submission, and the largest single-day profit below 50% of the sum of profit on all profitable days. If any one fails, the request is refused, the account continues and nothing is owed.

Tagsprop firm challengebest day ruleconsistency rulepayout review